MacLellan used the publicity gained from Ocean to release three of his own LPs, all of which enjoyed modest success. MacLellan, however, did not enjoy the public spotlight and retreated from the music scene, returning in the 80’s to perform at churches and penitentiaries throughout Canada.

Considered by many to be the unsung hero of Canadian music, McLellan received PRO Canada’s William Harold Moon Award for international achievement in 1987. He was posthumously inducted into the Canadian Country Music Associations Hall of Honour in 1995 and awarded the East Coast Music Association’s Helen Cheighton Lifetime Achievement Award in 1996. Put Your Hand in the Hand was declared a Canadian classic by SOCAN and is a standard in any gospel repertoire, having been recorded in 25 countries by over 100 different artists.